Sunday, January 07, 2007 2:37 PM With the new calendar year, we have redesigned the Consumer Reports
Cars Blog to give it more functionality for linking and sorting by
categories. If you access the blog via RSS feeds, please be sure to
update your reader to the new feed: http://blogs.consumerreports.org/cars/index.rdf
With the redesign, we have changed platforms and now have a new URL for you to bookmark: http://blogs.consumerreports.org/cars/
Last year was just the beginning for the Cars blog. For 2007, we'll
have more expert insights from the automotive team on our extensive
test program and also on the consumer-related issues that matter most
to you.
We will formally kickoff the new blog Sunday, January 7th, with
continuous, live coverage from the North American International Auto
Show in Detroit. Posts will be delivered right from the show floor at
the Cobo Conference/exhibition Center, giving you immediate insights
into the key news and unveilings from America's most significant auto
show. In addition, the auto editors and engineers will also provide
traditional coverage of more than 30 vehicles at: http://onlocation.consumerreports.org/AutoshowDetroit/
Words and photos will be updated continuously. Be sure to check back to
catch the latest information on vehicles, even if you read their
preview text. Starting Wednesday, CRTV will be posting videos from the
show hosted by the automotive team.
We appreciate you riding along with the blog in 2006, and look forward to accelerating into 2007. -- Jeff Bartlett
Wednesday, January 03, 2007 5:15 PM More staff insights on the latest test vehicles, from the January 2007 issue of Consumer Reports:
Gene Petersen: Sporty SUV or off-road SUV? Some people may truly
need an off-road vehicle or just want one, but the access, stiff ride,
and poor visibility in some are not worth the price of admission for
someone like me who drives predominately on public roads. A sporty SUV
sounds appealing and seems to be a growing sub-segment. The Nissan
Murano was one of the pioneers in this segment and still viewed as one
of the best. It looks slick, drives like a car with nimble handling and
comfortable ride, and the spunky V6 and continuously variable
transmission operate smoothly. The Acura RDX and Mazda CX-7 try to
compete in size and personality, but come up short with turbocharged
four-cylinder engines that are not terribly fuel efficient or pack the
low-end punch found in the Murano. The BMW X3 looks good on paper, but
lacks rock-solid reliability and comes with a big-SUV-like price tag.
Mike Quincy:
Sporty: I'm trying not to jump on the Nissan Murano bandwagon,
since a number of my colleagues have tagged this SUV as the one they'd
buy. Can't help it, though...the Murano has it all over these other
SUVs. For me, nothing combines the Murano's acceleration, good
steering, and snow-weather traction. The premium-only fuel, though, is
a bummer, and the ride and controls could be a tad better, but these
are negatives that are still easy to swallow.
Off road: Truthfully, I can't see a time in my life when I'd
need a tough-off-road focused SUV; I'd rather hike the trails some of
the vehicles traverse. My trip in Texas (see "The Texas truck
two-step"; "More Texas trucks - Digging in the dirt"; "Toyota Land
Cruiser - Aging gracefully") gave me some additional seat time in the
Jeep Wrangler and Toyota FJ Cruiser for some challenging off-road
driving. Both are well-designed for this purpose. For me, however, the
Wrangler's classic good looks and the top-down option put it slightly
ahead of the FJ. Plus, the deal-killer for the FJ is that it requires
premium fuel. But I'd choose the Nissan Xterra over both, since it's
nicer to drive on-road and has competitive off-road abilities. It also
has a roomier back seat for my young kids and a cargo area big enough
to haul stuff for a week's beach vacation.
Thursday, December 28, 2006 12:14 PM Continuing with staff insights on the latest test vehicles, from the January 2007 issue of Consumer Reports:
Tom Mutchler:
Sporty: It’s hard for me to get my head around some of the
prices in this test group considering what you get for that pile of
dough. The BMW X3 is fun, but $43K with no navigation?! And $37K for
the RDX, albeit it with lots of technowizardry, strikes me as a whole
lot of money for a small four-cylinder SUV. Although not in this test
group, the Toyota RAV4 V6 is the logical alternative pick, with an
amazing combination of a 6.7 second 0-60 time and 22 mpg overall in our
tests. However, I know from a long trip in it that I am not compatible
with the seats, although others have found them acceptable.
In the end, this choice is an easy one: I’d go with a Nissan Murano. It
has a wonderfully-smooth and powerful V6 with none of the hesitation of
the Mazda CX-7 or forced-induction heavy breathing of the Acura RDX.
The Murano is fun to drive, has more room than the RDX, and the front
seats fit me great. I’m not too keen of the George Jetson-inspired
gauge cluster, but I’d manage. Sometimes an older design is still a
goodie...
Off road: I hate sounding like a Nissan advertisement
here, but while the Nissan Xterra lacks the iconic styling of the FJ
Cruiser or Wrangler, it’s my pick for an off-road-ready SUV. It has
another wonderful V6, drives decently on-road, and is quite good
off-road. Best of all, it is easy enough to live with everyday, unlike
the Toyota FJ Cruiser or Jeep Wrangler.
Gabe Shenhar:
Sporty: Among the sporty SUVs, I’d take the BMW X3, hands down.
I had high hopes for the Acura RDX and Mazda CX-7 as being lower-priced
alternatives to the BMW, but neither satisfies like the X3. The BMW has
a punchy yet refined powertrain, satisfying agility, and good steering
feedback. Some of my colleagues complain about the X3’s ride, which is,
indeed, choppy, but it doesn’t crash into pot holes like the RDX, and
it provides good impact isolation. Comfortable seats, a huge sun roof,
and being just the right size -- not too big, not too small -- are
added pluses. And, it fits in my garage.
Off road: Among the off-road-ready vehicles, I’m almost
inclined to pick the Jeep Wrangler for its honesty and being true to
the original. It’s also the first Wrangler I’m not trying to swap with
someone else because this Jeep is rather tolerable in everyday life.
But the Wrangler’s noise, anemic engine, and stiff ride would get to me
eventually, I know.
| |